What Our Readers Think: Homeless Sex Offender Trailers

Add to the conversation by posting your thoughts in the comment section.

Earlier this week, County Legislator Jay Schneiderman announced that he is planning to hold an East End Community meeting seeking public comment on the county's homeless sex offender trailer program on Jan. 30. The announcement comes after Suffolk County Executive Steve Bellone missed a Jan. 1 deadline to shutter two controversial homeless sex offender trailers in Riverside and Westhampton.

Already the East End community is talking and Patch readers had a lot to say on the topic. The following is a round-up of their comments. What do you think? Keep the conversation going, by adding your thoughts in the comment section below.

Frank Wheeler wrote, "'Legislator Jay Schneiderman vowed to host a community meeting to let residents' voices be heard.' And then what's he going to do? NOTHING! Schneiderman is a clown!"

The One said, "We do NOT need 'public input'. Why not call it a good ol' lynch mob? They'll give out torches and pitchforks sponsored by whoever is running for office this year, or maybe that idiot Ahern, who has created many outright lies to justify her corporation's existence."

Deb added, "Not ALL sex offenders are the kind that take children and do what they want - in fact that group is a small percentage but yet the politicians make it a fact and place in the public's mind that each and every one of them are. A percentage are young men who at the age of 19 had a physical relationship with a girl of 16 of which the parents knew about but once the girl got mad about something she crys wolf and the parents of that girl call the authorities."

Frank Wheeler responded, "People don't wind up in the sex offender trailers because of underage consensual relations, and possession of child pornography IS a serious crime."

Anne Marie offered, "I tend to agree with you, Deb... but chances are that the majority of people will not want to consider your thoughts b/c people with certain proclivities are labeled as "BAD PEOPLE" forever and ever... and no one can force change upon another person who doesn't want it. People tend to ostracize and cast out what they fear (sometimes for good reason, but often times for not..) instead of working with people to bring about a positive social change. People also classify other people in an unconscious caste system and in turn treat them either fantastically or abhorrent in either regard. It's a societal fact... But, who am I to judge?"

Jay Whitmire wrote, "First, residence laws force ex offenders to live where ever they can, sometimes no where. Then when a housing solution is found, the places they are allowed to live have a cow because so many congregate there because there are so few places to live in the first place. This is like "projects" for ex-offenders. They didn't work for the poor, they won't work in this case."

Acacia added, "The registry was created to keep tabs on people who were already the "weirdos"; the people on the fringe of society who had already been convicted or were deemed to have some psycho-social disorder that were constantly in and out of institutions and were hard to keep track of to begin with. This is not as black and white as you think it is; the problem is much broader then you probably are willing to even conceptualize. If you want to hear real facts, do some homework. Research it. Don't just assume."

And BarT wrote, "If society doesn't wake up, they will be creating in underclass of citizens that they will have to foot the bill to provide for."

Related Reading:

  • Public Input Sought on Homeless Sex Offender Trailers
  • Schneiderman: Bellone Committed To Closing Sex Offender Trailers




Jerry King January 13, 2013 at 12:52 PM
WOW! I am delightfully surprised at the enlightened attitude and intelligence of most commenters. After reading nothing but fear mongering in the press and listening to pandering politicians who sound like they are willing to lynch, it is very refreshing. I thank you all for taking the time to express your thoughts AND I thank Patch for publishing.
LA Marshall January 13, 2013 at 04:44 PM
DOJ Statistics show that sex offenders as a class have only a 5% recidivism (repeat offense of the same general class) rate. Furthermore, many on the sex offender registry are those who have committed such crimes as "public indecency" (urinating behind a house would qualify) or consensual sex teen-on-teen (yes, this does happen!) or even "illegal restraint" in some jurisdictions, which includes, for example, the poor fellow who grabbed the arm of a child who ran out into the road and nearly got hit by a car. Remember that a "sex offender" need not have done something illegal in THIS state; he/she may have done something that another state considers a "sex crime". In some cases, this is only a misdemeanor. However, if registration is required in the state he/she is coming from, then he/she must register on moving to THIS state.
Vince Taldone January 13, 2013 at 05:04 PM
The residency notice laws are used everywhere by legislatures that don't know what to do in terms of adequate punishment or treatment but want to make constituents happy. The legislators have decided to make the sentences perhaps a bit too light and upon release, do not make serious treatment mandates, ankle and other tracking devices a requirement for a long, long time after as part of the sentence. Also, don't forget that because Suffolk County houses its homeless sex offenders in Southampton, West End county legislators have little incentive to resolve the problem. Many are fine with sending offenders from their districts to Southampton and then simply proceed to stick their heads into the sand. We need effective and fair laws with strong penalties for the crimes against children that concern us and not against those having one too many consensual but indiscrete sexual encounters on the beach. But none of this will get resolved without a county executive and legislature that are willing to develop a sound plan for dealing with this sad human condition both protecting communities from criminals and sharing the burden fairly among those communities.
The One January 14, 2013 at 08:47 PM
Glad to see my comment up there. The registry has created many evils and it is time to abolish it. oncefallendotcom for truth


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »