State Bill Would Rein in DEC Search Powers

Following the case of two Amagansett anglers, a bill proposed in Albany would cut back DEC authority in searching and seizing.

Following the case of a local brother and sister who were  after the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation took 90 pounds of their fish last July and , South Fork Assemblyman Fred Thiele is proposing legislation to put a check on DEC searches.

"Under the current process, the DEC is the police, the prosecutor, the judge, and jury, all before the case ever gets to court." Thiele said. "There is no check on the authority of the DEC. Citizens are entitled to some due process of law under the Constitution."

A DEC spokeswoman said via email on Friday, "We do not comment on proposed legislation."

Kelly Lester was initially charged with a misdemeanor for the alleged sale of shellfish to the public without a permit, but the charge was later dropped to a violation at arraignment. Paul, her brother, was charged with possession of untagged fluke and possession of over the limit fluke, which are violations, not considered a criminal offense under the statute.

According to their attorney, Daniel G. Rodgers, Thiele's proposed legislation is a "sea change."

"It's enormous," said Rodgers, who added that he was surprised to hear about the proposal last week. "This is putting an agency on notice, saying that they can't violate the constitution."

In early March, the . Rodgers says he has a receipt from Stuart's Fish Market with a check made out to the DEC for the fish obtained as a result of the search. The agency has yet to respond to their request, Rodgers said, and he has tentatively scheduled a press conference for next Monday calling for further investigation into the DEC's search practices, in addition to following the money trail he says must be made as a result of selling seized fish.

Bonnie Brady, executive director of the Long Island Commercial Fisherman's Association, said she hasn't yet had a chance to take a good look at Thiele's legislation. She'll be meeting with the assemblyman next week to go over his plan, among other issues, she said.

"We're looking at it now and we're happy Assemblyman Thiele is willing to help," she said. "We're looking to make sure this is something that receives widespread support."

Paul's brother Danny Lester said on Friday that while the legislation would be a good first step, much progress remains to be made.

"You gotta start someplace, so this legislation is going to be good. But these guys think they're cowboys and can do whatever they want," he said. "Maybe now they'll stop and think about what they're doing to people's lives."

In the end, the legislation still has to make it through the State Legislature and get Gov. Andrew Cuomo's signature. State Sen. Ken LaValle, R-Port Jefferson, is sponsoring the bill in the State Senate, according to Thiele's office.

"They're never going to stop until some of these politicians actually stop playing politics and look at what's going on," Lester said.

Brendan J. O'Reilly March 30, 2012 at 07:22 PM
Will commented via Southampton Patch's Facebook page: "They quickly found out that they had NO jurisdiction on Shinnecock."
eh April 01, 2012 at 02:19 PM
Probably a good thing - no Government agency should have broader search powers than another, - it should all be the same. Also, Simple, predictable enforcement and politicians staying out of field decisions, will make it easier for the public to know what to expect.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »